Which Sports Are Dangerous when You Have a Herniated Disc?
Living with a herniated disc does not mean giving up physical activity entirely, but it does require careful consideration of which sports and exercises are safe for your spine. A herniated disc occurs when the soft cushion between vertebrae bulges or ruptures, often causing pain, numbness, or weakness. While staying active is important for recovery and overall health, certain sports can aggravate your condition and potentially cause further damage. In this article, we explore the athletic activities you should avoid with a herniated disc, explain why they are problematic, and offer insights into making smarter choices for your spinal health.
High-Impact Sports that Stress Your Spine
Football and rugby
Contact sports like football and rugby top the list of activities to avoid when dealing with a herniated disc. These sports involve sudden collisions, tackles, and unpredictable physical contact that can jolt your spine and compress the already-compromised disc. The twisting motions required during gameplay, combined with the risk of being hit from unexpected angles, create a perfect storm for worsening your condition. Even wearing protective equipment cannot adequately shield your spine from the forces generated during these high-impact encounters.
Basketball and volleyball
While basketball and volleyball may seem less dangerous than full-contact sports, they pose significant risks due to their repetitive jumping and landing motions. Each time you jump and land, your spine absorbs impact forces that can be several times your body weight. This constant compression can aggravate a herniated disc and increase inflammation around the affected area. The quick pivoting movements and sudden directional changes these sports require also place rotational stress on your spine, potentially causing the disc material to protrude further.
Sports Involving Twisting and Rotation
Golf
Golf might appear to be a low-impact leisurely sport, but the golf swing is one of the worst movements for someone with a herniated disc. The powerful rotational force generated during a full swing places tremendous torque on your spine, particularly in the lower back. This twisting motion, combined with the flexion and extension components of the swing, can compress the herniated disc and irritate surrounding nerves. Many golfers with herniated discs report increased lower back pain after just a few holes.
Tennis and racquetball
Racquet sports demand quick lateral movements, sudden stops and starts, and powerful rotational swings. The serving motion in tennis, which involves hyperextension of the spine followed by rapid flexion and rotation, is particularly problematic for herniated discs. The asymmetrical nature of these sports, where you consistently rotate in one direction, can also create muscle imbalances that further stress your spine. The hard court surfaces provide little shock absorption, transmitting more impact directly to your back.
Heavy Lifting and Powerlifting Sports
Weightlifting and powerlifting
Exercises that involve heavy loads and spinal compression should be strictly avoided when you have a herniated disc. Deadlifts, squats, overhead presses, and other compound movements that load the spine can significantly increase pressure on the affected disc. Even with perfect form, the sheer weight involved in powerlifting competitions or heavy training sessions exceeds what a compromised disc can safely handle. The Valsalva maneuver, commonly used during heavy lifts to stabilize the core, increases intra-abdominal pressure and can push disc material further out of place.
CrossFit
CrossFit workouts often combine heavy lifting with high-intensity, explosive movements performed at speed. This combination is particularly dangerous for herniated disc sufferers. The emphasis on completing as many repetitions as possible in a limited time often leads to form breakdown, and when you are moving heavy weights quickly with compromised technique, your risk of further injury skyrockets. Olympic lifts like snatches and clean-and-jerks, staples of CrossFit programming, require explosive hip extension and spinal loading that can worsen disc herniation.
Running and High-Impact Cardio
Long-distance running
While running is often recommended for cardiovascular health, it can be problematic for those with herniated discs, especially in the lumbar spine. Each foot strike sends a shock wave through your body, and over the course of a long run, thousands of these impacts accumulate. Running on hard surfaces like concrete or asphalt amplifies this effect. The repetitive flexion of the hip that occurs with each stride can also pull on the lumbar spine, potentially aggravating the disc. Distance running’s cumulative impact makes it particularly risky compared to shorter cardiovascular activities.
Plyometrics and jump training
Box jumps, burpees, jump squats, and other plyometric exercises involve explosive movements and high-impact landings that compress the spine. The rapid deceleration forces when landing from a jump can be especially damaging to a herniated disc. These exercises are designed to develop power and explosiveness, but they achieve this by subjecting your body to forces well beyond normal activity levels. For someone with a compromised disc, this level of impact is simply too much.
Extreme Sports and Activities
Skiing and snowboarding
Downhill skiing and snowboarding combine several problematic elements: high speeds, unpredictable terrain, potential for falls, and jarring impacts from moguls or jumps. The twisting motions required to turn, particularly in skiing, place rotational stress on your spine. The risk of falling and landing hard on your back or experiencing a collision makes these activities particularly dangerous. Even experienced athletes cannot always control external factors on the slopes that might lead to sudden spine-jarring impacts.
Mountain biking
While cycling on flat terrain can be spine-friendly, mountain biking over rough trails subjects your back to constant jarring and vibration. Riding over rocks, roots, and drops creates repetitive compression forces that travel up through your seat and into your spine. The forward-leaning position on many mountain bikes also places your spine in flexion, a position that increases pressure on the anterior portion of discs. Crashes and falls in mountain biking can obviously cause severe damage to an already-herniated disc.
Making Safer Choices
Understanding which sports to avoid is just the first step. Consult with your physician, physical therapist, or spine specialist before returning to any athletic activity. These individuals can assess your specific condition and provide personalized recommendations. Lower-impact alternatives like swimming, water aerobics, walking on soft surfaces, and stationary cycling often provide excellent cardiovascular benefits without the spinal stress of high-impact sports. Remember that protecting your spine now will ensure you can return to the activities you love in the future.
If you have a herniated disc and want to continue enjoying sports-related activities, surgery may be discussed and potentially recommended to provide relief. For example, if your herniated disc is not responding to conservative treatment, a discectomy may be the best option. Although this is generally a very successful procedure, patients with a large hole in the outer ring of the disc have a significantly higher risk of reherniation following surgery. Often, the surgeon will not know the size of the hole until beginning surgery, and having a large hole in the outer ring of the disc more than doubles the risk of needing another operation. A new treatment, Barricaid, is a bone-anchored device designed to close this hole, and 95 percent of Barricaid patients did not undergo a reoperation due to reherniation in a 2-year study timeframe. This treatment is done immediately following the discectomy—during the same operation—and does not require any additional incisions or time in the hospital.
If you have any questions about the Barricaid treatment, ask your doctor or contact us today.
For full benefit/risk information, please visit: https://www.barricaid.com/instructions.
Comments